The University of Waikato - Te Whare Wānanga o Waikato
Faculty of Science and Engineering - Te Mātauranga Pūtaiao me te Pūkaha
Waikato Home Waikato Home > Science & Engineering > BioBlog
Staff + Student Login

facilitated communication?

Like me, you may have seen this article in the Herald (or some other paper) on Wednesday this week. It tells the story of Rom Houben who, after suffering severe injuries in a car accident, was left in what doctors diagnosed as a 'persistent vegetative state' for 23 years. His mother, however, was insistent that her son was still both conscious & alert. Eventually, PET scans of his brain indicated that this appeared to be the case, & the article tells us that after 3 years of intensive therapy "the 46-year-old is now communicating with one finger and a special touchscreen on his wheelchair."

If only things were that simple...

.

Before I go on, I have to say that the case described in this article represents one of my worst fears - being 'trapped' inside a body that's no longer capable of any independent movement, & being unable to communicate that fact - a phenomenon described as 'locked-in syndrome'. At least, if someone in this situation could even twitch some part of their body to indicate a conscious response, others would know that 'you' were in there. So why am I a bit 'iffy' about this story?

One reason is when you watch the video accompanying the story, it's plain that Mr Houben isn't actually independently using the keyboard - he's assisted by a carer who believes that, after 3 years of working with him, she can detect tiny muscle contractions in his finger to identify which letters he wishes to select on the touch-pad. (This fact isn't mentioned in the original  Herald article, although there is a slightly less credulous version here.) This is often described as 'facilitated communication' (a rather contentious field, as it turns out). I also noticed was that Mr Houben isn't looking directly at the screen much of the time, & at times his eyes appear to be closed. Despite this, his assisted typing is both fast & fluent (which is surprising - I have extreme difficulty in finding the right key if typing one-fingered & viewing the keyboard obliquely).

This is not to suggest that the carer doesn't genuinely believe that she is acting as an interpreter for Mr Houben. But it is to suggest that the media look at such stories with a more critical eye, instead of taking the whole thing at face value. There are certainly ways to examine what's happening, includng the following possibility put forward by one of Orac's readers in commenting on his post:

No one's suggested the simplest way to test this use of facilitated communication.

I think all would have to agree that Houben must be able to see and read in order for this technique to work. So all that's necessary are flashcards with short words on them. 4-5 letters each would do. A flashcard is shown to Houben but NOT the facilitator, and then Houben is asked to type that word. Any observer who stays in the room is similarly ignorant of the word, for double-blind purposes.

This way, the 'facilitator' doesn't have to be blinded while typing or otherwise disadvantaged; it doesn't matter that she can see the screen or has significant control over his hand. The test is just designed so that the questions have only one correct answer, and the facilitator does not know what that correct answer is.

PS And now I see that Darcy (over at Scepticon) has beaten me to it... Dr Steve Novella (who as a neurologist certainly knows more about the issue than I do!) has also provided a very thorough review of this particular case.

| | Comments (4)
Share via Email Share this on Twitter Share this on Google+ Share this on Facebook

4 Comments

Orac was also concerned about the blurring of lines between "initially vegetative state but recovering into minimally-conscious state" and "locked-in syndrome", since Houben's diagnosis seems to shift from one to the other depending on what best fits the narrative. Laureys' expertise is in the field of the former.

You'd think that if Houben has enough control over eye movements to read the computer display he's been provided with then he could communicate a lot more effectively, as well as convince any doubters, but the story has also shifted back and forth on this as well.

More skepticism from my good self.

PET scans of his brain indicated that this appeared to be the case
Did the Herald specifically mention PET scans? That's progress... other papers simply talk about "state-of-the-art brain scanning technology", which is getting into Woo Woo territory.

Hi Alison,

Apparently James Randi has also written on this, so you're in good company! :-)

I have to admit I was skeptical looking at it on the TV, too. It would seem simple to test, and you'd have to ask "why not" if they haven't.

It reminds me of a book I considered get for a Xmas present, Beijing Coma by Ma Jian. The main character is in some sort of conscious comatose state. I haven't read it, but it's hard to imagine a book where the main character can't do anything! Knowing Jian's books it'll be about the Chinese state, politics and policy (incl. Tienanmen) through the character's eyes.

I remember best his account of travelling through China, Red Dust.

In case you haven't seen yet Dr. Novella has just posted a follow-up to this

http://skepticblog.org/2010/02/15/dr-laureys-admits-facilitated-communication-failure/

and so have I, you may wish to for your readers as well.

Thanks, Darcy, I'll definitely do this. (Hadn't seen the follow-up by Dr Novella as my reading of others' blogs has been about as extensive as my own blogging in the last few days ie almost at homeopathic levels ;-)

Leave a comment

August 2013

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31

Recent Comments

  • Alison Campbell: Thanks, Darcy, I'll definitely do this. (Hadn't seen the follow-up read more
  • Darcy: In case you haven't seen yet Dr. Novella has just read more
  • Grant: Hi Alison, Apparently James Randi has also written on this, read more
  • herr doktor bimler: Orac was also concerned about the blurring of lines between read more